EBENEZER (2026): Bah, Humbug to the Critics!
Film critics baffle me sometimes.
And I say that as someone who has been one for nearly three decades.
There are movies that receive glowing reviews that leave me scratching my head, and there are perfectly enjoyable movies that get beaten to a bloody pulp by my colleagues for reasons I struggle to understand.
Which brings me to EBENEZER, the new Johnny Depp adaptation of Charles Dickens’ A CHRISTMAS CAROL.
Is it a home run?
No.
Is it an instant Christmas classic that I’ll revisit every December for the rest of my natural life?
Probably not.
But is the Rotten Tomatoes score, which has dipped into rotten territory, unnecessarily harsh and more than a little flippant?
Abso-freaking-lutely.
Some of my fellow critics are acting like Johnny Depp personally crawled down their chimneys and stole their Christmas presents.
Calm down, people.
EBENEZER is a perfectly enjoyable, occasionally frightening, wonderfully atmospheric retelling of one of literature’s most beloved stories. It has an excellent cast, terrific production design, and a leading man who seems delighted to be playing a character that requires him to be a little unhinged.
In other words, Johnny Depp being Johnny Depp.
I had a good time.
The Ghost of Christmas Past, Present, and Depp
Based on Charles Dickens’ 1843 novella A CHRISTMAS CAROL, EBENEZER transports audiences to Victorian London, where Ebenezer Scrooge (Johnny Depp) has apparently made it his life’s mission to be the most miserable son of a bitch in England.
Scrooge is wealthy, bitter, greedy, and utterly incapable of understanding why anyone would voluntarily experience happiness.
Christmas? Humbug.
Charity? Absolutely not.
Giving his employees a day off? You’d think somebody asked him to donate a kidney.
His long-suffering clerk, Bob Cratchit (Rupert Grint), works under miserable conditions while struggling to provide for his family, including his sickly young son, Tiny Tim (Freddie-Lee Grey). Meanwhile, Scrooge’s nephew Fred (Sam Claflin) continues extending invitations and kindness to an uncle who treats human affection like a contagious disease.
But on Christmas Eve, Scrooge receives an unexpected visitor.
His deceased business partner, Jacob Marley (Ian McKellen), returns from the grave to warn him that his miserable existence is leading toward an eternity of supernatural suffering.
And if Scrooge wants to avoid a similar fate, he’s going to have to do something he’s spent most of his life avoiding.
Take a good, hard look at himself.
Enter three spirits.
The Ghost of Christmas Past (Andrea Riseborough), the Ghost of Christmas Present (Tramell Tillman), and the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come take Scrooge on an increasingly unsettling journey through the choices that made him who he is, the people suffering because of his cruelty, and the terrifying future that awaits him if he refuses to change.
Arthur Conti portrays a younger Ebenezer, while Ellie Bamber appears as the woman who once offered him a different path in life. Daisy Ridley plays Clara, Fred’s wife, rounding out a terrific ensemble that gives the familiar story plenty of dramatic weight.
You know the story.
We’ve all seen it a hundred times.
But here’s where things get interesting.
This Isn’t Pirates of the Christmas Carol
I think Paramount may have done this movie a disservice with its marketing.
Watching the trailers, I got the distinct impression that we were about to experience PIRATES OF THE CHRISTMAS CAROL.
Johnny Depp! A flamboyant costume! Wild facial expressions! A little supernatural mayhem!
All that seemed missing was a bottle of rum and somebody shouting, “Why is the Christmas pudding gone?”
There was also the unmistakable sense that EBENEZER was being positioned as a major Hollywood comeback for Depp, whose career took a considerable detour following his very public legal battles with Amber Heard.
Here was an opportunity to introduce another quirky, larger-than-life character, perhaps even something that might capture a little of the magic that made Captain Jack Sparrow such a phenomenon.
And there’s certainly some of that Depp energy here.
But make no mistake.
EBENEZER is not a whimsical Christmas adventure.
This is a ghost story.
A DARK ghost story.
In fact, I’d argue that director Ti West’s interpretation is closer in spirit to Dickens’ original novella than many of the more cheerful adaptations we’ve become accustomed to watching during the holidays.
Yes, A CHRISTMAS CAROL is ultimately a story about redemption, forgiveness, and the possibility of becoming a better human being.
But it’s also a story about death, regret, poverty, human suffering, and the terrifying consequences of a life devoted entirely to selfishness.
Dickens didn’t just want readers to feel warm and fuzzy about Christmas.
He wanted to scare the hell out of them.
And West clearly understands that.
Ti West Knows His Way Around a Nightmare
Of all the directors I might have imagined tackling A CHRISTMAS CAROL, Ti West probably wouldn’t have been at the top of my list.
But the more I think about it, the more the pairing makes sense.
West is best known for his work in horror, particularly THE HOUSE OF THE DEVIL, THE INNKEEPERS, and his wonderfully twisted X trilogy: X, PEARL, and MAXXXINE.
This is a filmmaker who understands atmosphere, slow-building dread, and the power of making an audience uncomfortable.
And he brings those sensibilities to EBENEZER.
Victorian London is depicted as a cold, grimy, deeply unpleasant place. The streets are filthy, the interiors are claustrophobic, and even the Christmas decorations seem incapable of brightening Scrooge’s miserable existence.
The production design is terrific.
More importantly, the supernatural elements actually feel supernatural.
These aren’t simply three cheerful spirits dropping by to offer Scrooge a little holiday counseling.
They’re frightening reminders of the things he’s done, the opportunities he’s squandered, and the consequences he may never escape.
There’s a genuine horror sensibility running through the movie, and I appreciated that.
West doesn’t turn Dickens into a slasher film, nor does he attempt to reinvent the story with some ridiculous modern twist.
He simply allows the darker elements of the original material to breathe.
And honestly, I wish more adaptations would do that.
Johnny Depp Is Doing Johnny Depp Things
Let’s talk about the elephant in the room.
Johnny Depp.
Or, more specifically, Johnny Depp doing what Johnny Depp has spent much of his career doing extraordinarily well.
Playing weirdos.
From Edward Scissorhands to Willy Wonka, Sweeney Todd, the Mad Hatter, and Captain Jack Sparrow, Depp has built an impressive career portraying eccentric, exaggerated, and frequently bizarre characters.
Subtlety has never exactly been the primary selling point of his most recognizable performances.
And that’s fine.
When it works, it REALLY works.
In EBENEZER, Depp leans into Scrooge’s unpleasant personality with enormous enthusiasm. He’s cranky, theatrical, bitter, occasionally ridiculous, and clearly having a wonderful time making everyone around him miserable.
Is the performance a little much?
Sure.
But we’re talking about Ebenezer Scrooge, not a mild-mannered accountant working through some complicated feelings about his retirement portfolio.
Depp gives the role everything he’s got, and I found him enormously entertaining.
I also think his natural inclination toward eccentricity makes him a particularly effective choice for this version of the character.
He’s at his best when he’s allowed to be strange.
And Scrooge is a very strange man.
Now, whether Depp’s performance represents the beginning of some grand career renaissance remains to be seen. I’m not particularly interested in relitigating his personal life or the courtroom drama that dominated headlines several years ago.
I’m reviewing the movie in front of me.
And in the movie in front of me, Johnny Depp is pretty damn good.
An Excellent Cast Helps Carry the Load
Depp might be the main attraction, but the supporting cast is no collection of Christmas leftovers.
Rupert Grint brings an appealing warmth and vulnerability to Bob Cratchit. He’s the emotional counterweight to Scrooge’s relentless unpleasantness, reminding us that the old miser’s behavior has consequences extending far beyond his own miserable existence.
Sam Claflin is terrific as Fred, whose kindness toward his uncle feels increasingly miraculous given the amount of hostility he receives in return.
Daisy Ridley brings charm to Clara, and Arthur Conti and Ellie Bamber help flesh out the younger Scrooge’s emotional history.
Then there’s Ian McKellen.
Come on.
The man could read the ingredients on a box of instant mashed potatoes and make them sound like a Shakespearean tragedy.
As Jacob Marley, he’s an appropriately ominous presence, delivering the warning that launches Scrooge’s supernatural reckoning.
Andrea Riseborough and Tramell Tillman are also excellent as the spirits of Christmas Past and Present, giving their encounters with Scrooge a wonderfully unsettling quality.
The entire ensemble seems to understand the assignment.
And for a movie that spends much of its running time revisiting a story we already know, that’s no small accomplishment.
Who Exactly Is This Movie For?
Here’s where I think EBENEZER runs into its biggest problem.
I’m not entirely sure who the intended audience is.
Families looking for a cheerful holiday movie might be caught off guard by the PG-13 rating and the film’s genuinely frightening supernatural imagery.
Parents expecting a whimsical Johnny Depp adventure may discover that this particular trip through Victorian London is considerably darker than advertised.
Horror fans drawn in by Ti West’s involvement might be disappointed that the movie never fully embraces the kind of disturbing material he’s explored in his previous films.
And audiences hoping for a radically different interpretation of Dickens’ novel may be surprised by how closely the movie follows the familiar story.
It’s an unusual combination.
Too dark for some.
Not dark enough for others.
Too traditional for audiences wanting something new.
And perhaps too eccentric for viewers hoping for a more conventional Scrooge.
That’s a difficult needle to thread.
But here’s the thing.
None of that automatically makes EBENEZER a bad movie.
Sometimes a movie doesn’t fit neatly into the expectations created by its advertising campaign.
Sometimes it exists somewhere in the middle.
And sometimes the middle is a perfectly enjoyable place to be.
Bah, Humbug to the Rotten Tomatoes Score
Which brings me back to my fellow film critics.
Look, I understand why some people aren’t particularly impressed with EBENEZER.
It’s another adaptation of a story that’s been told countless times. Depp’s performance is undeniably theatrical. The pacing isn’t always perfect, and the movie doesn’t necessarily justify its existence by offering some revolutionary new interpretation.
Those are legitimate criticisms.
But reading some of the reactions, you’d think Ti West had personally desecrated Charles Dickens’ grave.
I don’t buy it.
There’s plenty to appreciate here, from the performances and production design to the atmosphere and the decision to treat A CHRISTMAS CAROL as the ghost story it has always been.
Not every movie needs to be a masterpiece.
Not every adaptation needs to reinvent the wheel.
And not every enjoyable night at the movies needs to become part of your annual holiday viewing tradition.
I liked EBENEZER.
There. I said it.
Johnny Depp gives 110 percent. The supporting cast is excellent. Ti West’s horror sensibilities bring something worthwhile to the familiar material, and the production itself looks terrific.
Will I watch it again?
Probably not.
There are too many other versions of A CHRISTMAS CAROL I’d rather revisit, and I can’t imagine this one replacing any of my personal favorites.
But I had fun spending a couple of hours with it.
And sometimes that’s enough.
Maybe my colleagues should take a little advice from the movie they’re so eager to criticize.
Lighten up.
It’s Christmas.
B.
Bah, humbug to the critics.
Check out the movie trailer for EBENEZER below, or check out the podcast for the KVNU For The People Movie Show if you missed the review last Friday.